Relationship Dealbreakers: Common Ones and How to Find Yours
The most common relationship dealbreakers, how they differ from red flags and preferences, and a simple way to decide which non-negotiables are really yours.
A dealbreaker is the thing that ends it. Not the thing that annoys you, not the thing you’d change if you could, but the thing you can’t live with, no matter how much else is right.
Most lists of dealbreakers online mix very different things together: cheating next to bad texting habits, wanting kids next to chewing loudly. That makes them fun to read and not much help when you’re trying to figure out what actually matters to you.
This guide does it differently. It separates true dealbreakers from red flags and from plain preferences, walks through the ones that come up most, and gives you a simple way to work out your own list, so you don’t end up with fifty “musts” or none at all.
Dealbreaker, red flag or preference?
These three words get used as if they mean the same thing. They don’t, and mixing them up leads people to leave good relationships or stay in bad ones.
- A preference is something you’d like. Tall, funny, likes hiking, good cook. Nice to have. Plenty of happy couples have few of each other’s preferences.
- A dealbreaker is a difference in what two people want from life that can’t be bridged. Wanting kids when the other person doesn’t. Needing a shared faith. Wanting monogamy when the other wants an open relationship. Neither person is wrong. They just can’t both get what they need.
- A red flag is about how someone treats you. Lying, controlling, cruelty, contempt, any kind of violence. A red flag isn’t a mismatch. It’s a warning sign about safety and respect, and it’s a reason to step back even if everything else lines up.
That last line matters. You can have zero dealbreakers with someone and still need to leave because of red flags. And you can hit a real dealbreaker with someone who is kind, honest and good to you. That second case is the painful one, and the one this article is mostly about.
The most common relationship dealbreakers
Everyone’s list is different, but certain topics come up again and again. They have one thing in common: there’s very little middle ground.
Kids
This is the classic. You can compromise on where to live or how often to see friends. You can’t have half a child. Having kids already can matter just as much, for people who aren’t ready to date someone with a family.
- Do you want children?Yes, definitelyProbablyNot sureProbably notDefinitely not
- How do you feel about dating someone who already has children?Love itOpen to itPrefer notNot for me
Monogamy and fidelity
What kind of relationship you want, and what counts as cheating, is a dealbreaker area for many people. It’s also one people often assume instead of asking. Two people can both say “monogamous” and mean different things about flirting, exes, porn or a dating app left on a phone.
- What kind of relationship do you want?Strictly monogamousMonogamous, but fantasies and flirting talk are fineOpen relationshipPolyamorous, more than one committed partnerSwinging, together with other couples
- How do you feel about your partner watching porn?Fine either wayFine if we watch togetherUncomfortable with itIt is a dealbreaker
Faith, values and politics
For some people, faith is one part of life. For others, it’s the center of it, and sharing it with a partner isn’t optional. Politics works the same way: for some couples a difference is a running joke, for others it touches values they can’t set aside.
- How important is it that your partner shares your faith?Not importantMust share it
- How do you feel about a partner with different beliefs on big moral issues?DealbreakerWe can respect differences
Notice that these ask how much it matters, not just what you believe. That’s usually where the real gap is. We go deeper in religious and political differences in a relationship.
Other common ones
- Marriage itself. One person wants to marry, the other never wants to.
- Where to live. One won’t leave their hometown, the other has a career that needs them to move.
- Substances. Smoking, heavy drinking, cannabis, gambling. For some people any amount is a no, often because of what they saw growing up.
- Money habits. Serious debt, hiding spending, or wildly different ideas of saving and security.
- Sex. A big, lasting gap in how much intimacy each person needs, especially when one of you won’t talk about it.
- Pets and allergies. It sounds small until one of you has three dogs and the other can’t breathe around them.
- Ambition and pace of life. One wants to build a business and work sixty hours, the other wants a quiet life with a lot of time together.
How to decide your own dealbreakers
A good dealbreaker list is short. If everything is a must, nobody can meet it, and you end up rejecting people over things that would never have mattered. If nothing is, you can end up years into a relationship with someone who wants a completely different life.
Here’s a simple way to sort it out. For anything you think might be a dealbreaker, ask yourself:
- Would I resent this in five years? Not “would it bug me,” but would I feel I’d given up something important about my life?
- Is it about the life we’d build, or about a type? “Must want kids” is about your life. “Must be over six feet” is about a type. Types are preferences, even strong ones.
- Has it already cost me something? If you stayed through a difference before and it ended badly, that’s real information about what you need.
- Is it mine, or someone else’s? Sometimes a “never” came from a parent, a friend or a past partner. Make sure you still agree with it.
- Could I talk about it openly with a partner? If you’d be embarrassed to say it out loud, think about why. It might be a fear more than a need.
You’ll likely end up with a handful of real dealbreakers, a few more “not ideal, but worth talking about,” and a long list of nice-to-haves. That’s healthy.
When to bring up dealbreakers
There’s a lot of advice about not “scaring someone off” on a first date. There’s some truth to it: nobody wants a first coffee that feels like a job interview. But waiting too long has a cost too, because the longer you’re together, the harder it is to walk away from a real mismatch.
- Early, lightly. In the first few dates, you can mention the big things in passing. “I really want a family someday” is a normal thing to say over dinner.
- Before you’re exclusive. Kids, monogamy, marriage and faith are worth a real conversation before you commit to each other.
- Before big steps. Moving in, getting engaged, combining money. Each step is a good moment to check that nothing has changed.
If you’re heading toward marriage, we put together a full set of premarital questions to ask that covers the big dealbreaker areas in detail.
What to do when you hit one
Finding a real dealbreaker with someone you love is hard. A few things that help:
- Make sure it’s real. Ask what’s behind their answer. “I don’t want kids” sometimes means “not now,” “not with how my childhood went,” or “not unless things are stable.” Sometimes it means exactly what it says.
- Don’t bargain with your core needs. Agreeing to something you deeply don’t want, to keep the relationship, tends to come back later as resentment.
- Don’t count on change. People do change their minds. Planning your life around the hope that they will is risky for both of you.
- Get help thinking it through. A couples counselor can help you both say what you really want without it turning into a fight.
- Be kind if it ends. Ending over a real dealbreaker doesn’t mean anyone failed. It means you were honest.
How SoulRatio handles dealbreakers
In SoulRatio you can mark what you need in a partner: must have, nice to have, does not matter, not ideal, or dealbreaker. Your Soul Ratio then checks the other person’s answers about themselves against your list, and yours against theirs. Must-haves get checked, possible dealbreakers get flagged, and the “not ideal” items show up as worth a conversation instead of a verdict.
Beyond your list, the questionnaire has about 340 questions across 15 areas, from kids and money to intimacy, faith and how you handle conflict. Each person answers privately, and nobody sees your answers without your permission. You see one Soul Ratio for the two of you, a breakdown by area, and what’s worth talking about.
It works for couples and for singles. In singles mode, you answer once and see your Soul Ratio with every mutual like before the first message, so you know about the big mismatches before you invest weeks in someone. For singles, answering and showing up on the ratio map are free, and the $10-a-year plan is for when you want to connect. Couples pay $10 a year per person before they start. For more on what a full compatibility check covers, see our couples compatibility test guide.
Common questions
What are common dealbreakers in a relationship?
The ones that come up most are differences on having kids, monogamy and what counts as cheating, faith, wanting to marry, where to live, substance use, money habits and very different needs for intimacy. What they share is that there’s little middle ground.
What is the difference between a dealbreaker and a red flag?
A dealbreaker is a difference in what two people want from life that can’t be bridged, like one wanting kids and the other not. A red flag is about how someone treats you, like lying, control or cruelty. A red flag is a reason to step back even when you agree on everything else.
How many dealbreakers should you have?
There’s no right number, but a short list works best. A handful of true dealbreakers, a few things that are not ideal but worth discussing, and the rest as preferences. If everything is a must, almost nobody can meet it.
Is it bad to have dealbreakers?
No. Knowing what you can’t live with saves both people time and heartache. The trouble starts when preferences, like height or hobbies, get treated as dealbreakers, or when real dealbreakers get ignored in the hope they’ll go away.
When should you talk about dealbreakers with someone you’re dating?
Mention the big ones lightly in the first few dates, have a real conversation about kids, monogamy, marriage and faith before you become exclusive, and check in again before big steps like moving in or getting engaged.